Rate xianxia series you are reading out of a score of 10 (10 = your fav)

124

Comments

  • CD 10/10
    great story, a lot of adventures, a lot of varieties, more power levels, hard working MC, less drama, less romance (which xianxia is is)...

    ISSTH 10/10
    everything is great in this story except chasing parts.. er gen just abuses chasing scenes, which i think it is his weakest point, deep writing style, alot of varieties in the story, not limited to cliche format throughout the story... less drama and romance oriented - which is a BIG + in my view

    DE 10/10
    another IET masterpiece, excellent story layout (except i dont like how Ji Ning got his original name after reincarnation, a cliche to me), 8 books into the story and Ji Ning still hasnt met his wife/lover... which is so much better than stories like DD and Divine Throne where almost chapter 1 - MC, chapter 2 - MC's lover/wife and they are already soooo much in deep love....

    ST 10/10
    one of my alltime most favorites, the level is adventure is just off the chart, very interesting story where you just wanna read more and more. this is another IET masterpiece, story frame is similar to his other works, which i love...

    SS 10/10
    yet another masterpiece by IET, again story is built on adventure and training rather than romance and unnecessary lowy-dowy romantic moment descriptions..

    DD 2/10
    i should stop reading this, but since i have read half of it, i just wanna see it to the end.. one of the novels where i skip more than half of each chapter and read dialogs only.. the description part is that much and that boring to me... this story is i would say based on 35% tournaments, 35% romance/drama, 10% fighting, 5% training, the rest - miscellaneous... why i think this story is weak is because, the characters are set nearly from the start and are limited, the power level set from start and limited, and whole story revolves around these characters... fight scenes are very boring and repetitive.. very slow novel

    BTTH 1/10
    it is so bad that i dropped it, similar to DD, i dont wanna comment anymore

    ATG 4/10
    great setting at the start but it gets ruined by repetition, drama/romance, unnecessary narration, illogical MC powerup... the only good thing i can say is that there was a sex in the story, unlike DD, BTTH, DT... this is one of those novels that i skip usually half of the chapters and go to the end of it see what happened... very slow novel...

    TDG 8/10
    fairly new novel, 417 chapters so far, i find it very interesting, similar to IET novels (in some aspects), the only downside is the amount of drama/romance moments and MC is incredibly stupidly innocent... just take those beauties downtown...

    MGA 8/10
    great story, fast paced, every chapter you see some progress, MC is too stupid at times (similar to naruto and the kyuubi that saves his ass all the time), but adventure oriented, a lot less tournaments, less creepy drama moments - instead adult actions...overall it is a great story which i enjoy

    MGS 7/10
    fast paced story, i find it more interesting because it has less tournaments, MC acts like adult and less merciful, hardworking, a bit too lucky though... less drama/romance, again a big + in my view... xianxia novels need to have adventure/fights/training at the core of the story, not drama/romance... there novels that are pure drama/romance and that's great, they are categorized as such... but some novels are called xianxia but drama/romance instead... wasting some of the readers time...

    Divine Throne 3/10
    another creepy drama/romance novel, just too creepy... stopped reading months ago, i hope i dont go back, another novel that wasted my time... just dont call it xianxia and i will never bother with it...

    LMS 10/10
    best virtual reality game genre novel, love it to no end, except for MC real life part, i find everything else very interesting... great novel

    ARK 6/10
    good VRG novel, but not as good as LMS

    ARK 2 no rating
    read 2 volumes i think and stopped - not dropped... didnt find it very interesting at the time, may come back to it..

    Arifureta 2/10

    started off great but then drama invaded and i dropped it...

    Re:Monster 9/10
    great reincarnation story, i find it very interesting, too bad there's no good translation team taking over it.. MT is killing me..

    TGR 6/10
    started off great, but too shallow and MC is too damn lucky and smart that is too unrealistic... to me a very weak story, dialogs are very shallow, and everything is sooo smoothly layed-out for MC..

    overall, i like xianxia genre, and i enjoy more or less all of them ( it is OK to have weak or strong stories), except when the story turns into drama/romance...

    to me, when xianxia novel is composed of endless tournaments and drama/romance, it says to me that the author is not a good xianxia writer.. because these are the easiest things to write and fill up the chapter instead of progressing the story.
  • edited January 2016
    ok..  i have read few xianxia , only CD being the one that is completed. so here goes-

    Douluo dalu- 9/10
    CD- 8.5/10
    ISSTH- 8/10 (it got better now so i upped it)
    WDKQ- 7/10
    TDG-7.5/10
    Zhang Long- 4/10
    Chaotic Sword god- 3/10
    Desolate era- 6/10
    BTTH - 6.5/10
    MGA- 7.5/10
    Heavenly Jewel change- 6/10
    Skyfire avenue- 6/10
    ATG - 6.5/10

    ISSTH has potential, as they have lord fifth $$squeak squeak$$
    DOuluo dalu is awesome.
    P.S these were considered after ignoring the mediocre language used in translations.
  • it seems like no one in here read Conquest , true martial world and transcending the nine heavens
    All 3 are really good.

    Worthy of Wuxiaworld front page features IMO.  
  • edited February 2016
    Oh, what a nice thread. I'm fairly new to xianxias and webnovels in general and I can only read english translated works, so my perspective's pretty limited. Even so, I'll boldly try my hand at this:

    I Shall Seal The Heavens - 8.0
    > Probably my favorite so far. Er Gen's poetic style and the way he interweaves his arcs and characters really accentuates his qualities as a writer, even though he should learn to give side characters more shape, volume and limelight. The story's pretty straight-forward and the mc's very relatable; its tone's well-rounded, with good comedy, smart moves, nice insights, heroics and even some romance (even though it's a bit lacking in bro-moments and evil schemes); it's easy to gulp down chapters one after another and hardly ever we as readers get bored or disapointed, since the situations the author presents are almost always new and refreshing, with satisfying and sometimes epic conclusions.
    > Also, cuddos for Deathblade clan. They crack me up!

    Transcending The Nine Heavens - 8.0
    > There's too few chapters around to be conclusive here, but what I've seen so far's pretty marvelous. Fenglin Tianxia has a very peculiar and overbearing style, that's at one time insulting and addicting. He just throws whatever in your face and you just can't say you're disliking the experience! The mc's ingenious and resourceful to a fault, but that can't be considered too OP, since there're crouching tigers and hidden dragons everywhere in this world, that's filled to the brim with conspiracies, plots and schemes. When compared to other xianxias I read, this one's pretty oddly shaped, with more focus on politics and intrigues and less on cultivation and striving for individual strength.

    Otherwordly Evil Monarch - 7.5
    > This series's just a blast to read. Fenglin Tianxia's style's even more barbaric in this work, even more rude and dirty, but just as addictive. TTNH does have its comedic moments, but the whole vibe there's of a sinister hue, whereas OEM's acidity can't be considered anything but comedic gold. I caught myself laughing out loud several times while reading OEM's characters ranting about and insulting one another. Still, there's only like 80 chapters available and it seems it'll be dropped soon by its current translator... what a shame.

    Renegade Immortal (Xian Ni) - 6.5
    > After reading ISSTH, RI does seem a rehash of themes explored there (I know it should be the opposite, but I just so happen to have started reading RI this week, so that's that). Even so, the story has its own flavor and the mc does have some spunk that separates him from ISSTH's. That said, Xian Ni's writing's not so polished as Er Gen's later work. Can't say much more though, since there's just like 50 chapters or so available right now.

    Coiling Dragon - 5.5
    > My first xianxia. I confess I did force myself to go through this series as I was reading it, so I can't really say it was a fully pleasant experience. IET's style's very taxing and the amount of repetitions gets on your nerve pretty fast; also, the author's lack of proportional and dimensional understanding's confusing and borderlines the unbearable. There's some nice ideas here and there and the mc's a nice enough fella, with some good friends and whatnot, but very few gets developed or any attention at all, even though the best arc by far's Reynolds' adventure and the best emotional punch's thrown when we get to know about Yale's tragic demise. IET should really focus more on mini-stories about side characters, since there's where he shines the most afterall. Also, rushed and unsatisfying end.

    Tales of Demons and Gods - 5.0
    > It's on the chopping board. Started with some cool ideas and concepts but its gimmicks are blowing air. In fact, some of the qualities we could see in the plot structure and narrative choices just vanished some time ago and are nowhere to be seen; it seems the more the story progresses, the worse it gets. I don't know if Mad Snail prepared himself properly for this series, but there's a lot of times I get myself thinking "that's just sloppy writing" or "it's dragging again". Wouldn't recommend to anyone at this point.

    Below this threshold there's those I dropped, mainly Stellar Transformations and Desolate Era. I'm preparing myself to start maybe Skyfire Avenue or World of Cultivation, dunno.
  • Hmm my list is-

    I Shall Seal The Heavens-10

    Death March-9

    Coiling Dragon-9(except the last 2 volumes)

    Duoluo Dalu- 9

    Battle Through the Heavens-9

    Wu Dong Qian Kun-9

    The Great Ruler-9

    Against the Gods-8

    Desolate Era-8

    Tales of Demons and Gods-8

    Martial God Asura-7

    Peerless Martial God-7

    Long Live Summons!-6

  • edited February 2016
    Good (9-10) = ISSTH, World of Cultivation, Ze Tian Ji, Transcending The Nine Heaven (kinda underrated, if its hosted on WW would be very popular),                                            HJC.

    Decent (7-8) = IET novels, ATG, TDG, TMW.

    Bad (below 5) = PMG (lol sooooo bad).


  • edited February 2016
    Xian ni 10
    ISSTH 2: reading near 400 chapter. been a chore. have to force myself to read it. because people say it gets more fun. Thinking of dropping it.

    So I have read all latest chapter and I have to give it 2, one point down from 3. 


    tales of demon and god 1 some fun at the beginning but lose it quite fast.

    read some other novel but lost interest not that far into the story.

    Anyone can suggest me other novel than Xian ni?
  • Xian Ni - 10
    Ze Tian Ji - 10
    ISSTH - 9
    Reincarnator - 6
    Swallowed Star - 5
    Terror Infinity - 5
    CD - 5
    ST - 5
    MGA - 4
    ATG - 3

    My "top" 10. Although, I honestly feel that only the first three are really a good read. I used to be obsessed with the genre and read every new chapter of practially every series each day, but after some time I got tired of it. Most stories are just too similar, too "Mary Sue-ish" and way too much self-insert wish fulfilling. Maybe I'm just disillusioned after overdosing.

  • edited March 2016
    Sovereign of Three Realms - 6.5
    > The setting's very much similar to Otherwordly Evil Monarch, with traces of Tales of Demons and Gods around the mc. Plow Days writing's a bit simplistic and lazy at times, specially when it'd be a great time to show just exactly how awesome and all-knowledgeable the mc really is, but all in all it's a good read, if not a bit lacking in craftiness and acidity.
  • bump.. any ranking updates?
  • I don't know why World of Immortals got low ranking on Novelupdates.  

    It's a really good read.  

    8.5/10  
  • MikeR said:
    I don't know why World of Immortals got low ranking on Novelupdates.  
    I haven't read it
    but for me reviews don't mean shit
    either manga novels or movies (due to too much overrating/underrating)
    each person should have its own review and don't attach too much importance to other people views especially those so-called experts and critics
    this is the reason we have a masquerade called Oscars
  • Five Way Heaven is really good too

    8.5/10   

    A bit confusing in the first 2-3 chapters but it grows strength to strength from there.

    alyschu is translating so hopefully Wuxiaworld will recruit it since alyschu is already translating Against the Gods.

    Martial World is 9/10 just as good as True Martial World.  Too bad GravityTales recruit it and benefiting from it because Wuxiaworld didn't.  Such a good series and Wuxiaworld missed out.  

    Shrouded is 8.5/10.   Written by the author of Perfect World.  Another promising series that Wuxiaworld should recruit.  
  • Realms in the Firmament - 5,5
    > The newest novel by Fenglin Tianxia's quite a disappointment so far. It's got none of the bite and acidity that make his previous works such a joy to read and the setting's super-generic, with none of the political struggles or aristocratic disputes we've seen previously. All in all, it's just not very bright. But maybe it'll improve, who knows. The author definitely has it in him to make it soar.
  • Novelupdates rating aren't worth shit. Just look at Jin Yong novels ratings over there, some gets rating of 3.0, or Gu Long also 3.0. And the reviews are unreliable at best. And the tags untrustworthy, too many false or exaggerated tags.
  • Out of ten...
    ISSTH- 9, some arcs 10
    CD- 7
    ATG- 7
    MGA- 6
    CC- 7
    TDG- 8
    Apart from ISSTH, every novel Ihave read so far gets repetitive and I don't feel like reading them unless the chapters pile up. sigh

  • ISSTH - 9

    DE - 8.5

    None of Tomatoes stories are great but he himself is a great story teller. There is no character development and the ending is similar (become supreme being and revive relatives etc) but somehow I still can't stop reading it

    LLS - 8

    ATG - 1

    SOTR - 0.5

    CSG - 0


  • Desolate Era - 10

    Will it remain a 10? I don't know, but it's the novel I'm enjoying the most atm, IET's novels are so exciting.

    CD - 9
    -Completed-
    ST-8
    - Soon to complete-

    Swallowed Star - 7

    ISSTH - 6

     It's not that I think it's bad, it's just that some of the content is really not my taste. For example, I hate long battle scenes, and it seems like some of the confrontations in ISSTH goes on and on and on for chapters, resulting in me skimming a lot of them. I really enjoyed book 3, if I were to judge that individually, it would be a 10.


  • edited May 2016
    CD- 9/10

    ISSTH- 10/10

    ATG- 8.5/10
    ... would be higher if not for the authors constant need to make MC an underdog and keep power lvl so low even when common sense dictates otherwise (seriously bro, do you even math?) I won't go on as I don't want to spoil ppl.

    TDG-.... idk what to say about this one.. it has a great foundation. It was a 10/10 w/o question for me UNTIL I found out the author went all depressed and started releasing 1 chapter every 1-2 weeks and the story took a lititle bit of a sadISH route. So I pretty much dropped it due to the fact I don't want to be disappointed in what could have been the greatest novel I'd ever read.

    DD- 9/10

    MGA- 5/10
    I dropped it, it was good till none of the female roles become relevant, I like harems, but not if the ppl in the harem are useless or don't contribute to the story. 

    ST- 8.5/10
    To me it seemed like a copy and paste of CD. Ik it wasn't entirely but for the most part. 

    USIAW ( Upgrade Specialist In Another World)... 
    Another I don't know how I should rank, the story seems great but to be honest (if you have a problem with what I'm about to say, bite me) I think HE MAN should stop translating. Ik alot of you like him, I would too IF HE ACTUALLY STAYED TRUE TO HIS WORD. Ik real life doesn't always let you do what you have planned, but it's a constant thing with him, his translations are great, but his lack of availability hurts the novel being translated. Sure most of you might say, just lnmtl the rest, well I honestly don't like reading mtl cuz it gives me headaches having to rearrange every single sentence that's why I'm here, cuz of translated novels. But anyways, I guess an 8/10 
  • edited May 2016
    AC - Apocalypse Cockroach - ??? (insufficient sample size)
    ATG - Against the Gods - 7/10
    BTTH - Battle through the heavens - 4/10
    CCM - Close combat mage - 1/10
    CD - Coiling Dragon - 5.5/10
    DD - demons diary - 5/10
    Disciple - My disciple died yet again - 6/10
    GDW - God and Devil World - 5.5/10
    GOR - Gate of revelation/Gate of apocalypse - 7/10
    ISSTH - I shall seal the heavens - 7.5/10
    LLS - Long live summons - 5/10
    MGA - Martial God Asura - 4/10
    MW - Martial world - 7/10
    PMG - Peerless Martial God - 3/10
    RMJI - a record of a mortal's journey to immortality - 7.5/10
    RPG - RPG world - 4/10
    SOTR - Sovereign of the Three Realms - 6/10
    TDG - Tales of demons and gods - 6.5/10
    TGR - The Great Ruler - 3/10
    TMW - True martial world - 8.5/10
    TTW - the trembling worldd - ???
    USAW - Upgrade specialist in a new world - 5/10
    WDQK - Wu Dong Qian Kun - 3/10
    WMW - Warlock Magus World - 6.5/10
    WoC - world of cultivation - 5/10
    XN - Xian Ni/Renegade Immortal - ???
    ZL - zhan long - 2/10
    ZTJ - Ze Tian Ji - 7/10
  • edited May 2016
    CD 9/10 The world is extremely well build and balanced with OP beasts that grow very slowly and weak humans that grow faster. The cultivation method at the end is original : instead of gathering energie, they have to understand laws. It's well-thought and it is not senseless. The other character are not entirely developped, but it is a xianxia story so we can't entirely blame IET on that. All in all, it doesn't disapointed and is extremely addictive. No harem which is a plus for me. Too much luck involved.

    DE 10/10 One of the best xianxias I have ever readed. I was the most impressed in the Dao debate. They explain to you at this moment that MC gets stronger for a real reason : When he learns the dao of the sword he lives by the sword, for the sword and dies for the sword. At this point, i wasn't asking myself why he got strong, but why wouldn't he be ? The auhors has created such an OP world with friendgod that can regenerate, have six arms, created clones with just a single hair, control space, time etc. He didn't just make the MC OP, he made everyone op which make it very interesting.

    ST : 5 drop for now. Too much luck involved. There was even a trial where they were measuring luck, and we saw that the MC was so lucky, he won everything while being the weakest... This is ridiculous. Then he got to the divine realm, and the author dragged the meeting of the MC with his pets/brother for a whole book. And the only thing he was doing is being chase around because he was so dumb he gave his name to everybody.The only interesting scene that happened was the moment when he acquired the red dragon (I dont remember his name). His figth was awesome and that's it. The MC's plot armor is so strong : he can hide indefinitly in the Jiang Lang realm and cultivate since it's defense is impossible to breach. And when he arives at the end of the black hole realm he should have been stronger that late mystic realm expert. But he is not and I don't even understand what the author is doing any longer. How the hell will he beat the peng emperor ? I dropped it to read smth else

    MGA : 2. The only thing I like about the MC is that he is ruthless. But every MC is like this in xianxia. The MC is extremely dumb at the beggining and he doesn't improve at all. And it's almost like every person he meets is a bad guy except for 2 or three dudes. If I was the UC of this world I would have destroyed it long ago since everyone seems to to be an ass. I had to drop it.

    Conquest : 9/10 Funny hero, great story, good fight.

    ATG : 5 The beggining was good.But why does the MC need to destroy a whole clan including children and innocent who aren't even cultivator. ? He says it was to protect his loved ones but he could have easily hired mercenaries to protect them  since he rich. Or they could have been protected by his first wife who is the princess of an empire and has sky realm expert under her command and millions of other experts. So he had to destroy the ones who didn't even have cultivation bases just for this ? It was just the easiest and the most retarded, autistic way to protect his loved ones. And harems pisses me off + the author is dragging just to be paid longer.

    God and devil world : 8 .Racist, harem, autistic and retarded decisions by the MC sometimes but not to serious. Otherwise good.
  • edited May 2016
    TDG 6 It's always the same thing. The characters of this xianxia always have an op item but they do not know how to use it and they use it  for example to make mosquitoes flee istead of using it for cultivation. The MC however will know how to use it to make cash or to become OP etc. The mc can be pretty annoying with his elders sometimes.

    ISSTH 7.5 Too much details for things that do not make sense (like a head form with lightning WTF). The plot is always the same trop : getting luck from misfortunes.The  fights  drag on for many chapter for a character that will not matter in the chapters that will come, boring, too much explanation for things that do not have any sense (my body is a cauldron, i am the recipe etc etc). Too much poesie. Otherwise good
  • edited May 2016
    TDG 6 It's always the same thing. The characters of this xianxia always have an op item but they do not know how to use it and they use it  for example to make mosquitoes flee istead of using it for cultivation. The MC however will know how to use it to make cash or to become OP etc. The mc can be pretty annoying with his elders sometimes.

    ISSTH 7.5 Too much details for things that do not make sense (like a head form with lightning WTF). The plot is always the same trop : getting luck from misfortunes.The  fights  drag on for many chapter for a character that will not matter in the chapters that will come, boring, too much explanation for things that do not have any sense (my body is a cauldron, i am the recipe etc etc). Too much poesie. Otherwise good
    Made me giggle.
  • So i'm pretty new to the xianxia/wuxia scene, and light novels in general. I've completed only a few series, but i'll try to adequately describe my opinions on them
    BTTH- 6/10  I admit that i've mostly been reading the manga for this particular series, but from what i hear, the ln is based on the manga. It starts off pretty ok, but as the story continues, you get a distinct lack of direction that the author is trying to take. It seems more episodic, than an actual continous story. Overaĺl, i found this novel very average, with the main highlight being a few of its characters(medusa).
    ATG- 4/10 This has to be THE most disapointing series. It starts of so promisingly, and the initial arcs are actually extremely engaging. But, as the novel goes on, we see the mc turn from a genuinely likeable guy, who makes the right desicions, to a guy who lets his penis take descisions for him. The whole story after the burning heaven arc ( forgot the proper name) goes this way. Mc potrayed weak- meets girl- girl helps mc- mc fights guys stronger than him- mc never loses- mc saves girl- girl falls in love- they have sex- they marry. This is the novel. Don't get me wrong, harems are fine with me, if handled properly, like in mushoku tensei, but in case of this, it is just ridiculous. At the latest count, our hero has banged like 7 different women. Overall, the only good aspect to this novel is the sex, and the initial few arcs.
    ISSTH 8/10 Started this series very recently, and I have completed about 200 chaps. Initial impressions are very good. Likeable mc, good plot of side characters, romantic hints, and a very engaging plot. And kudos to the teanslator for doing such a good job with this novel.
    CD 7/10 Oh the nostalgia!! This was my very first ln, that i read about a year ago. Now, this rating might be a bit biased considering that i am very fond of this series, so take it with a grain of salt. Like ISSTH, it has a likeable mc, a really nice caste of side characters, and a really good romantic subplot. The initial arc ( before he leaves to the higher realm or whatever) was really enjoyable, and i would prolly give it a 8 or 9. But the series gets vey stale later on. Another thing that i like about this ln is the used of westernized names for the characters. Makes it really easy for new readers to figure out wh's who
  • ATG-10 badass MC, ruthless, for someone even crazy since he burned down an entire clan just because they kidnapped his family(but if u consider that in his previous life he killed milions of ppl in order to survive and get revenge it's not so surprising). Well I don't mind the repetitive stories if it involves his harem.
    MGA-10 ruthless MC, kinda impulsive at the beginning (never thinking of the consequences of his actions) but later changes in better
    BTTH-6 reading it just because can't find anything better to read atm...
    ISSTH-5 one word boring. ..till chapter 650...only the mastiff story was enjoyable. ...the rest just get strong and so on for no reason, just to become immortal while leaving your humanity behind...not my type of MC
  • edited June 2016
    Coiling Dragon 10/10
    I give 10 point, because this is my 1st complete novel. I get started addicted to read another novel.
    Worst plot when the MC fall in love with Woman and got break up.
    And Bebe way of talk is so fun.

    Tales of Demons and Gods - 3/10
    I give 3 point    what??? I read this because some reference after reading the manga. Because after reading this novel, I can't start hype anymore with reading any manga.
    The whole plot is masterpiece and the way of Author tell the hype is so cool.
    Worst plot Draconic realm, too much politically thing
    And why somehow I don't get the hype with their level thing. (Heavenly axis, or Dragon ream, or Ancestor thing don't give me ghostbump)
    They work better with gold rank, black gold rank, and legend rank somehow.

    Battle Through The Heaven 5/10
    Good novel, but too much self praise MC until i got boring with that.

    Wu Dong Qian Kun 5/10
    The fated duel LD and LLT is so epic!!
    again with too much self praise MC until i got boring with that.

    Desolate Era 8/10
    WTH this novel, the way their talk is so noble. Awesome
    Worst part is no Comedy, don't read it.

    Again The Gods 10/10
    All of you always talk about conquering the world. But other novel can't do a thing about conquering woman in the world.
    Only this novel!! hahaha..
  • some more rating since the last time I posted

    The Emperor's Domination 9.5/10
    I'm Really A Superstar 9.5/10

  • ATG - 6/10 - I pretty much liked it in the beginning, but the story gets very repetitive, everything revolves around some sect offending Yun Che or his chick triggering a revenge plot. The author forgets about the rules of the world he created and seems to be dragging the story.
    MGA - 5.5/10 - same as ATG, slightly worse though
    CD - 6/10 - the story is very boring until he leaves his first world, I liked the cultivation methods though. Revenges weren't excessive which I liked.
    ST - 2/10 - I think it's the only novel I dropped before catching up to the recent translations. Very boring, MC seemed to be an idiot to me.
    Desolate Era - 8.5/10 - one of my favourites - I dislike IET's characters - they are plain and stupid, but the universe he creates is epic. Nevertheless, MC gets too much plot armor here...
    Dragon-marked War God - 5/10 - nothing original about it - just a mix of ATG, MGA and probably some more novels. I liked the MC way of dealing with his enemies, but how many times the author's gonna tell me that MC is a genius over geniuses, a deity, an unstoppable demon? wtf.
    Douluo Dalu - 8/10 - nice plot, great characters, not enough cruelty though, even the bad guys don't seem to be very bad.
    HJC - 8.5/10 - ^ pretty much the same
    WMW - 10/10 - best novel I've read so far - lots of references to Coiling Dragon but everything else is very original - cruel, pragmatic MC who puts self interest in the first place living in a cultivation world that doesn't depend on sudden insights. So far I've only read the translated chapters but the story makes me think that it won't have a good ending or at least not for anyone else except MC.
    COL - 4/10 - boring.
  • Dilios said:
    ATG-10 badass MC, ruthless, for someone even crazy since he burned down an entire clan just because they kidnapped his family(but if u consider that in his previous life he killed milions of ppl in order to survive and get revenge it's not so surprising). Well I don't mind the repetitive stories if it involves his harem.
    MGA-10 ruthless MC, kinda impulsive at the beginning (never thinking of the consequences of his actions) but later changes in better
    BTTH-6 reading it just because can't find anything better to read atm...
    ISSTH-5 one word boring. ..till chapter 650...only the mastiff story was enjoyable. ...the rest just get strong and so on for no reason, just to become immortal while leaving your humanity behind...not my type of MC
    I see you berating ISSTH to promote ATG crap, I don't even have word to describe you, you're just a crap addict, can't appreciate fine writings.

  • Coiling Dragon 10/10
    I give 10 point, because this is my 1st complete novel. I get started addicted to read another novel.
    Worst plot when the MC fall in love with Woman and got break up.
    And Bebe way of talk is so fun.

    Tales of Demons and Gods - 3/10
    I give 3 point    what??? I read this because some reference after reading the manga. Because after reading this novel, I can't start hype anymore with reading any manga.
    The whole plot is masterpiece and the way of Author tell the hype is so cool.
    Worst plot Draconic realm, too much politically thing
    And why somehow I don't get the hype with their level thing. (Heavenly axis, or Dragon ream, or Ancestor thing don't give me ghostbump)
    They work better with gold rank, black gold rank, and legend rank somehow.

    Battle Through The Heaven 5/10
    Good novel, but too much self praise MC until i got boring with that.

    Wu Dong Qian Kun 5/10
    The fated duel LD and LLT is so epic!!
    again with too much self praise MC until i got boring with that.

    Desolate Era 8/10
    WTH this novel, the way their talk is so noble. Awesome
    Worst part is no Comedy, don't read it.

    Again The Gods 10/10
    All of you always talk about conquering the world. But other novel can't do a thing about conquering woman in the world.
    Only this novel!! hahaha..
    That's not conquering since it's fking unreal, I don't mind harem but that was a masturbation story, where MC is the center of the universe, everything go his way, all women fall for him, all rival turning his step stone.
Sign In or Register to comment.